peterme.com

Links, thoughts, and essays from Peter Merholz

“Live 2.0″ – the value of live events

Posted on | February 4, 2009 | 6 Comments

At TED University yesterday, Jim McCarthy talked about the phenomenon of the value of recorded media plunges whereas the value of live, in-person experiences increases. He refers to this as Live 2.0. He pointed out that in 1985, the cost of a CD and a concert ticket were roughly the same. Recorded media has lowered in price (if you think about buying whole albums on iTunes) whereas concerts have gone up and up. Considering he was saying this in a room of people who paid $6,000 to attend, even though all the talks can be seen free online, clearly, there’s something there.

When this trend is discussed, the typical explanation involves people wanting to be together, with one another, because we’re fundamentally social, etc. etc. That’s obviously correct, but insufficient — people in 1985 wanted that togetherness as much as we do today. Other forces at play must have dramatically shifted the value.

A couple ideas:

  • The decreasing price of recorded media means people have money left over, and are able to funnel that money into other things they love, such as concerts.
  • Information about live events is easier to come across, thanks to the internet (whether simply sharing of forwarded emails, or tools like Upcoming). So more people know about these events increasing demand, increasing prices, because supply is limited.

    Your thoughts?

    Comments

    6 Responses to ““Live 2.0″ – the value of live events”

    1. James
      February 5th, 2009 @ 6:16 am

      I agree with both your points, but I would add a third factor: I think the most significant change has been the increased cost and quality of production for live shows. The scale and professionalism of the spectacle for the biggest names (Rolling Stones, Celine Dion, Cirque de Solei, and so on) has stepped up considerably since the mid-1990s. Opera tickets have always been expensive due to the high production values, and a major rock concert or circus or other live performance with the same quality and opulence will need to reach for the same level of ticket prices. That pushes up the relative price for the entire market, even those without as much glam, since people’s expectations have been set fairly high.

    2. James
      February 5th, 2009 @ 6:23 am

      Oh, I thought of a fourth factor: talent salaries. Professional sports is the best example: salaries for the top performers are large enough to directly impact ticket prices. You hire Beckham/Posh for a billion dollars, somebody’s gotta pay for that. I assume there has been similar salary pressure in the other talent industries: music, film, comedy, whatever. It’s all about the bling, baby.

    3. Julius
      February 5th, 2009 @ 6:32 am

      Great post.

      Your point makes more sense to me for entertainment, where increased piracy has driven to sell stars live at higher prices.

      To me that does not apply to conferences. Increased prices at conferences are the last attempt to front the new waive of user generated events, where the same people attend and network, at a small or no cost.

      The trend started by Meetups, Barcamps, Tweetups and the like are getting people together in a more interactive fashion.

      If conferences are selling speakers’ knowledge, expertise and networking, you can get pretty much all of it for free at several free gigs.

      To me expert status is something that is not marketable anymore with ridiculous ROI’s but rather on an inclusive model.

      Given that, we’ll always have the iPhone or Playstation of events but on a concpetual basis rather than on bogus 80-20 rules which belong to 1900.

      Of course this is my opinion but I am collecting case studies in this perspective and the trend is growing.

      Julius

    4. Jim McCarthy
      February 10th, 2009 @ 5:47 pm

      Peter, thanks for talking about this!

      One point I made briefly in my talk is that, in fact, we have a decreasing set of options for in person socializing versus the past. You’ve probably read ‘Bowling Alone,’ but if you happen to have missed it, check it out.

      So yes, we wanted to socialize just as much then as we do now, but we have (or at least we find) fewer ways to do it. At least in person.

      BTW, if anyone is interested in listening to the talk, I recorded basically the same thing at this link on the Live 2.0 site:

      http://www.download-not-available.com/quick-takes/live-20-ted-presentation-now-available

      Thanks again for talking about this! I’m glad you got something out of my talk.

    5. Tim Cullen
      February 13th, 2009 @ 4:04 pm

      This phenomenon is all about supply curves.

      Recorded (or, perhaps better stated for the purposes of this discussion, “non-live”) media is not just cheaper, as you noted above, but it’s also more ubiquitous. Chronologically, the walkman, iPod, and now iPhone streaming Pandora or Last.fm have brought us quite close to the reality of a cloud-based universal jukebox. Add to that the ease of copying and sharing, and you’ll see there’s been a massive shift in the supply curve of non-live music & performance.

      In contrast, the supply of live performances, at least on a per-performer basis, has probably remained about level and will remain so until cloning is much cheaper and more reliable.

      These changes have also revealed new insights into the economically complementary nature of live and non-live performances.

    6. Jim McCarthy
      February 18th, 2009 @ 1:38 pm

      Totally agreed, Tim. “Cheaper and easier to get” is the phrase I frequently use.

    Leave a Reply





  • Hello

  • Archives

  • Better Tag Cloud
    barclays wealth interview questions barclays offshore savings account barclays wealth management london barclays wealth hans crescent standard bank of south africa swift code barclays wealth online helpdesk sb offshore barclays wealth barclays private equity sells deb www standardbank za barclays wealth terms and conditions standardbank co za internet banking barclayswealth.ch barclays online banking credit card standard bank private banking barclays wealth miami standard bank online internet banking barclays offshore banking barclays wealth online banking Standard Online offshore barclays wealth uk barclays wealth funds barclays private bank geneva barclays private equity france barclays wealth management boston barclays wealth management france barclays wealth isa set up barclays online banking standard bank cellphone banking standard bank online banking barclays wealth jobs barclays offshore barclays wealth cardiff barclays wealth uk careers barclays wealth management internship barclays wealth international private bank barclays wealth dallas standard bank private banking criteria barclays wealth risk sboff barclays wealth mitch cox barclays offshore business banking barclays wealth relationship manager www barclayswealth.com barclays offshore interest rates barclays private wealth management barclays wealth hires investment representatives standard bank internet banking barclays wealth legal barclays wealth financial planning barclays wealth philadelphia barclays wealth offices barclays wealth uk www.sboff.com barclays offshore savings barclays wealth international private bank barclays wealth competitors barclays private clients international barclays wealth management barclays wealth woolwich plan managers barclays bank bank south africa barclays wealth bank barclays wealth bristol bankonline sboff standard bank offshore isle of man barclays wealth defined returns barclays wealth barclays capital barclays wealth logo barclays wealth managers france standard bank private banking qualify barclays assets sboff com the standard bank of south africa limited barclays wealth individual barclays wealth atlanta barclays wealth los angeles standard bank offshore online barclays wealth contact barclayswealth.com international bank offshore barclays wealth trustees guernsey limited sboff.com barclays private investors barclays offshore mortgages international barclays online banking barclays wealth recruitment barclays wealth telephone number barclays wealth boston barclays wealth usa barclays wealth gamma barclays wealth protected investments barclays private wealth careers barclays wealth insights barclays wealth card www offshore barclays.com barclays wealth interview questions standard bank online share trading standardbank co za standard bank online trading account standard bank private equity standard bank offshore group jersey barclays private bank & trust limited barclays wealth defined returns plan barklays wealth standard bank za barclays wealth new york barclays wealth americas barclays wealth locations barclays wealth review standard bank online business banking barclays wealth san francisco barclays private equity careers barclays wealth account standard bank wealth barclays private bank barclays wealth linkedin standard bank private banking requirements barclays private bank & trust cayman ltd barclays private equity barclays private clients international ltd address standardbank mobile barclays wealth graduate south africa offshore fnb za barclays wealth report www.barclayswealth.com individual barclays online private banking barclays wealth fees barclays wealth emerging markets optimiser barclays wealth management news private banking wealth management barclays wealth advisory barclayswealthcareers.com barclays wealth international knightsbridge standard bank of south africa barclays private finance barclays wealth employees barclays wealth dc barclays wealth target growth plan barclays wealth family business forum barclays wealth directors sboff bank barclays wealth london telephone number barclays wealth website barclays wealth dubai the standard bank of south africa barclays wealth trust barclayswealth.com individual private client wealth management barclays wealth fixed income bond barclays wealth online banking login standard bank offshore rates barclays wealth telephone interview standard bank wealth management standard bank south africa branches barclays private equity india barclays private clients international guernsey barclays wealth international address standard bank offshore wealth mangement barclays private bank new york barclays wealth wikipedia barclays wealth banking barclays wealth birmingham office absa za standard bank uk barclays online banking barclays wealth nigeria barclays wealth london contact standardbank barclays wealth canada barclays wealth research standardbank south africa barclays wealth in london standard bank private bank criteria barclays wealth gibraltar barclays wealth login lloyds tsb offshore Standard Bank Jersey barclays wealth houston businessonline standardbank co za barclays wealth interest rates barclays wealth annual report barclays wealth london office barclays wealth phone interview barclays private account barclays wealth atlanta barclays offshore account barclays wealth regular income bond barclays wealth internship lloydstsboffshore encrypt standardbank co za barclays wealth hong kong barclays wealth birmingham barclays wealth philanthropy barclays wealth products barclays wealth vacancies barclays wealth embark barclays wealth ceo barclays wealth management glasgow www.barclayswealth.com ibank barclays online banking log in barclays wealth news barclays wealth real estate standardbank internet banking www barclays com barclays wealth wiki sboff offshore barclayswealth.com barclays private equity deb group barclaysbank standard bank online banking login barclays wealth private barclays wealth leeds barclays online banking international barclays wealth london barclays wealth glasgow careers barclays offshore mortgage rates barclays private banking barclays bank offshore barclays online banking kenya offshore business barclays offshore instant access barclays private banker salary barclays wealth interview barclays wealth operations barclays wealth debit card barclays wealth india barclays wealth fund prices barclays wealth careers fnb bank barclays online banking india barclays private pension barclays wealth chicago barclays online banking register barclays wealth email standard bank za barclays wealth hr barclays private equity european fund iii barclays wealth france barclays wealth report 2009 standard bank offshore jersey barclays wealth history offshore africa barclays private bank & trust cayman ltd barclays wealth internship barclays wealth douglas barclays wealth fixed growth bond online banking barclays offshore lloyds international barclays online banking barclays wealth management new york barclays offshore bank account standardbank za ibank international barclays barclays wealth funds limited standardbank co za internet barclays private bank new york barclays wealth washington dc standardbank offshore barclays wealth tay house barclays wealth bonuses private banking wealth barclays wealth banking swire pacific offshore africa standard bank online banking namibia barclays private equity deb barclays wealth address barclays wealth newcastle barclays wealth international lloydstsb offshore online barclays wealth geneva standard bank private bank barclayswealth barclays offshore structured products barclays private wealth careers standard bank online business barclays wealth dublin standard bank online banking registration barclays wealth assessment centre barclays wealth international online banking barclays online banking barclays wealth bonus barclays online banking business barclays global investors standard bank in south africa standard bank cell phone banking standard bank south africa swift code barclays wealth uk accumulator barclays wealth phone number barclays wealth logon barclays private wealth online standard bank private banking qualifying criteria barclays wealth onlin barclays offshore bank barclays offshore solutions barclays wealth uae barclays wealth bond standard bank private clients barclays private asset management monaco www.barclayswealth.com international barclays wealth careers uk standard bank private banking sandton africa offshore services barclays private bank 59 grosvenor street standard bank south africa barclays private bank & trust isle of man limited barclays private bank & trust jersey barclays capital barclays offshore accounts barclays wealth americas